Why DIY Builders Hurt Your SEO Rankings

DIY website builders advertise easy solutions for your business website. But their platforms limit your search rankings in ways you might not expect. Learn why custom websites perform better for SEO and what you might be missing with your DIY site.

Written by

Shane Castegnaro

Published on

March 12, 2025
Blog
Why DIY Builders Hurt Your SEO Rankings

You’ve seen the ads. Build a website in minutes with Wix, Squarespace, or Weebly. Pick a template, change some colors, type in your text – done. Sounds easy, right? But when it comes to search engine optimization (SEO), these platforms hide some hard truths that can hold back your business growth and limit your online success.

The Basic Benefits (And What You Miss)

These website builders offer quick setup and simple designs that might work well for personal projects or hobby sites. The templates look clean, and the drag-and-drop interfaces make it easy to get started. Yet business websites need much more than just good looks – they need strong technical foundations to rank well in search results and attract customers.

Speed and Performance Matter

Google ranks faster websites higher in search results, and this is where DIY builders start to show their limitations. These platforms come with pre-built features and functions that slow down your pages, whether you use them or not. Custom-built websites, like those we create at Brick House, start with clean, efficient code designed for speed and performance from the ground up.

Control Over Your SEO Success

Most website builder platforms restrict access to fundamental SEO tools and features that make a real difference in search rankings. When businesses try to improve their search rankings on these tools, they often face these critical limitations:

  • Access to basic HTML code remains locked down, preventing the addition of structured data markup that helps search engines better understand your content and business information
  • Technical SEO features come with extra monthly costs through premium subscriptions, turning basic optimization into an ongoing expense
  • Image optimization tools lack advanced controls, leading to slower page loads and missed opportunities in visual search results
  • URL structures stay rigid and platform-controlled, making it harder to create the clean, keyword-rich web addresses that both users and search engines prefer

Mobile Performance and Search Rankings

Sure, DIY sites might look fine on your phone at first glance. But Google looks deeper. They track how fast pages load, how quick buttons respond, and how stable the layout stays while loading – what they call Core Web Vitals. These platforms often fall short on these key measurements, and that hurts your search rankings.

Custom websites give you complete control over mobile performance. At Brick House, we build sites that deliver fast, smooth experiences across all devices, helping you rank better in mobile search results – which now make up most web searches.

Understanding the True Cost

DIY website builders market themselves as budget-friendly options, but the real costs add up quickly in both time and money:

  • Monthly platform subscription fees that never end
  • Premium feature upgrades needed for basic SEO functionality
  • Hours spent learning platform limitations and finding workarounds
  • Lost business opportunities from poor search rankings
  • Extra costs for third-party tools to fill feature gaps
  • Time spent managing multiple platform subscriptions

The Power of Custom Development

A custom-built website from Brick House gives you complete control over your online presence. Our sites come with all SEO features built in from the start, not as expensive add-ons. You own your website outright, eliminating ongoing platform fees. Most importantly, your site works flawlessly on all devices and ranks better in local searches.

Our team in Berkshire County understands the local market and builds sites that connect with customers. We focus on creating websites that not only look professional but drive real business results. And with our ongoing SEO services, we keep improving your rankings month after month to bring more local customers to your business.

Making an Informed Choice

Stop letting a DIY website hold back your growth. If your current site isn’t bringing in the customers you want, let’s talk. Our Berkshire County team will look at where you’re at now and map out a plan to get your business ranking better in local searches.

Give us a call at Brick House. We’ll show you what’s possible when you move beyond the limits of DIY builders.

Contact Us

Frequently Asked Questions

We understand that you may have some questions related to the topic of this article, so we’ve compiled this list of FAQs to help you get the information you need quickly and easily.

If you don’t see the answer to your question, please reach out to us directly. 

Contact Us

Yes, DIY builders add extra code and features that slow down your site speed – a key ranking factor for Google. They also limit your control over important SEO elements like custom meta descriptions, schema markup, and URL structures.

Think of a custom website as an investment in your business growth. While DIY platforms charge monthly fees forever, plus extra costs for basic SEO features, a custom website is something you own outright. You avoid recurring platform charges and get all the SEO tools you need built right in from the start.

Looking good on phones is just the start. Google measures specific mobile performance metrics like load time and response speed. DIY builders often score poorly on these measurements, which directly impacts your rankings.

Most DIY platforms lock basic SEO features behind premium subscriptions, and some technical SEO elements can’t be added at all. Custom websites include all SEO capabilities from the start, giving you better control over your rankings.

While every business is different, custom websites typically start showing ranking improvements within 3-6 months. Our ongoing SEO services help maintain and improve those rankings over time through active optimization.

Recent Articles

View All